Home Blog Reserving : Bornhuetter–Ferguson & Loss Ratio methods

Reserving : Bornhuetter–Ferguson & Loss Ratio methods

Published on

Reserving: Bornhuetter-Ferguson & Loss Ratio, two reserving methods complementary to the Chain Ladder method

What are the differences between the Chain Ladder method and Bornhuetter-Ferguson or Loss-Ratio methods?

As a regulatory obligation, and in order to cover its future commitments to its policyholders, it is essential for an insurer to have an accurate and correct estimate of its reserves.

As detailed in our previous article, the Chain Ladder method is the most widely used non-life reserving method on the market. However, there are situations in which it cannot be used or is unsuitable. In these cases, two other categories of deterministic methods are very commonly used by non-life insurers:

  • Bornhuetter-Ferguson and Loss ratio methods, based on loss ratios (Claims/Premiums: S/P): methods that we will discuss in this article.
  • And the Average Cost and Average Cost per Claim methods, based on average costs: methods that we will present to you shortly in a future article.

Below, we present the Bornhuetter-Ferguson and Loss ratio methods, which are very useful, and even essential, as a complement to the Chain Ladder in order to obtain a good estimate of reserves.


Bornhuetter-Ferguson & Loss Ratio reserving methods: Presentation & Applications

What the Bornhuetter-Ferguson and Loss Ratio methods have in common is that they both use an exogenous input: the S/P ratios and information on the ultimate earned premiums expected by the insurer.

  • The Bornhuetter-Ferguson method combines an estimate of the loss ratios with an estimate of the ultimate earned premiums. Multiplying these two elements gives an estimate of the ultimate cost of claims, which will then be redistributed – to complete the claims triangle – using the rate of settlement observed for the risk studied.
  • The loss ratio method works in exactly the same way as the Bornhuetter-Ferguson method, but it stops at the estimate of the ultimate cost of claims; no amount is redistributed.

The Bornhuetter-Ferguson method is frequently used as a complement to the Chain Ladder method. Its advantage is that it is not directly linked to historical data (and therefore to the associated claims triangle), which makes it an excellent alternative for estimating the ultimate for the most recent periods of origin.

Paid Triangle BF Loss Ratio Method

Indeed, for the oldest periods of origin, the years being greatly developed, confidence in the application of the Chain Ladder LDFs is relatively high. However, for the most recent periods of origin, and in particular the most recent, an inconsistency in a historical amount will have a very strong impact on the calculated reserve and could lead the insurer into situations that it should avoid. For example, in the case of the last original period which only contains a historical amount:

  • if the period is abnormally loss-making (amounts settled are too high), then the projection will lead to over-reserving, which will have an impact on the insurer’s accounts;
  • and conversely, if the period is abnormally low in claims (amounts settled too low), then the projection will result in under-reserving, which could lead to a shortfall in funds at the time of future claims settlements.

It is therefore common for non-life insurers to use the Chain Ladder method, except in the most recent original periods when the Bornhuetter-Ferguson method is used.

Reserves calculation BF Loss Ratio Method

Bornhuetter-Ferguson & Loss Ratio reserving methods: Advantages & Limitations

Like all reserving methods, the Bornhuetter-Ferguson and Loss Ratio methods have their own advantages and limitations, which should be taken into account when choosing the appropriate method to use.

Advantages and limitations of the Bornhuetter-Ferguson method

Advantages of the Bornhuetter-Ferguson method

+ The method is not linked to the observed claims triangle and is therefore less sensitive to data anomalies.

+ Introduction of parameters outside the triangles

+ Appropriate method for estimating the most recent periods

Limitations of the Bornhuetter-Ferguson method

– Result highly dependent on the quality of the claims ratios

– Method nevertheless partially linked to the observed claims triangle via the use of development factors

Advantages & Limitations of the Loss Ratio

Advantages of the Loss Ratio method

+ Easy to implement

+ Relevant for recent or less mature portfolios

Limitations of the Loss Ratio method

– As with the Bornhuetter-Ferguson method, results depend heavily on the quality of the loss ratios

– Can be disconnected from observed reality

– Should be avoided as soon as the insurer has sufficient historical data


Written by our experts

Read also

  • How to choose the right insurance reserving method?

    Reserving

    How do you know that the reserving methods you are currently using are the most appropriate one? Read our article and discover the four non life reserving methods you need to master throughout your actuarial career.

  • How to transform my reserving process?

    Reserving

    Discover why it is important to transform your insurance reserving process and its associated challenges.

  • Reserving: Average cost and Average cost per claim methods

    Reserving

    Average cost and average cost per claim reserving methods: how and when to use them? A clear guide for all actuarial professionals and any actuary who is an expert in reserving.